Comments on: Discipline and How Non-Punitive Parenting Works https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/ Fri, 29 Mar 2013 02:45:31 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.7.12 By: Happy parents = Happy kids? » a hippie with a minivan https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/#comment-3267 Fri, 29 Mar 2013 02:45:31 +0000 http://paxye.com/blog/?p=4466#comment-3267 […] The more we meet our children’s needs, the more they will know they can count on us and the more independent they will become because they always know there is someone to fall back on. This is the one of the fundamentals of a secure attachment and this type of attachment will flow into all of the stages of childhood until a child becomes an adult and is ready to be on their own and make it easier to parent. (read my post on Discipline and how non-punitive parenting works) […]

]]>
By: Sophie Crépeau https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/#comment-3266 Wed, 20 Feb 2013 02:57:19 +0000 http://paxye.com/blog/?p=4466#comment-3266 Merci Mélissa j’adore ton message. Il vient appuyer ma vision de la discipline. Je ne suis pas seule, alors ça ne doit pas être si mauvais… Et tu as raison de dire que l’on a le droit de se tromper ou de pogner les nerds. Tu me fais penser aussi au fait que mon enfant, fondamentalement, veut me faire plaisir et veux être avec moi. C’est juste qu’il a de drôle façon de la montrer comme courrir partout, sauter à l’intérieur de mon chandail, chercher ma réaction même de façon négative.

]]>
By: Melissa https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/#comment-3265 Tue, 19 Feb 2013 23:41:06 +0000 http://paxye.com/blog/?p=4466#comment-3265 In reply to rachel.

If I thought is was truly important, I would just ask the child to sit or kneel and tell them why… “I am scared that you might fall and hurt yourself so could you sit or kneel please?”

If they do it, say thank you.

If they continue to stand I would ask again… “It makes really uncomfortable to see you standing up as I am scared that you will get hurt, is there a reason why you don’t want to sit or kneel?” Then if they give a reason, try to come up with a solution that works for both of you. Or make a game or show them something fun that has them kneeling or sitting in order to do it.

If they continue… “OK… I have asked you a couple times and I don’t like feeling scared that you will get hurt, so how about we move to something else”

If kneeling or sitting is the rule of the bath, and there is no way come to an understanding that works for both of you after have asked and tried to figure it out, then the natural consequence is that bath time is over. (but it shouldn’t be used as a threat nor should it be made into a big deal… it is just a matter of fact.)

Also, it is important to think of the rules in your house. Why are they there? Use that explanation when asking something of your child. Rules without good reasons are much harder to enforce because they often don’t make sense. Ask them to find a solution that will work and make them part of the rule making or ask them to find rules…

Never talk in absolutes… don’t say something like “don’t jump on the couch because if you do, you are going to fall.” If a child then jumps and doesn’t fall then the rule doesn’t work… because they jumped and didn’t fall. Kids can be very litteral like that. If you say that you are nervous that they may fall and you don’t like seeing them hurt, or you don’t want the fabric to rip because it is getting a bit old, well then say that. They can’t argue about what you may feel and the rules make more sense.

Personally, I might get some anti-slip pads in the bath if I was scared… because I know that with my kids standing in the bath can be really fun.

]]>
By: rachel https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/#comment-3264 Tue, 19 Feb 2013 21:22:45 +0000 http://paxye.com/blog/?p=4466#comment-3264 Agreed.

I would like to hear an attached parenting solution to a given situation: a preschool aged child is taking a bath with their parent, stands up in the bath, parent expresses the danger of standing in the tub and states the need to remain seated or on knees while in the tub. Child continues to stand. What would your response/action be? (I would imagine this could be a scenery that other parents have experienced.)

Thanks

]]>
By: Sunday Surf: Discipline, Chemicals and Parenting | Radical Ramblings https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/#comment-3263 Mon, 16 Apr 2012 23:05:26 +0000 http://paxye.com/blog/?p=4466#comment-3263 […] recently discovered the blog A Hippie With a Minivan, and I love what I’m reading. This post about positive discipline is my favourite so far. If you want a concise, well-written explanation of […]

]]>
By: paxye https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/#comment-3262 Fri, 13 Apr 2012 01:20:36 +0000 http://paxye.com/blog/?p=4466#comment-3262 In reply to aNonyMous.

Thanks and Welcome to the blog!… it took a while to put my thoughts into without it turning into a book but I am proud of how it turned out. I do hope you come back a visit again!

]]>
By: Praise and the proverbial carrot… » a hippie with a minivan https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/#comment-3261 Fri, 13 Apr 2012 00:56:07 +0000 http://paxye.com/blog/?p=4466#comment-3261 […] and doing things for themselves instead of doing things to make others happy or proud. Like discipline and punishment, it is about external motivation vs internal motivation. Like punishment, praise only works in […]

]]>
By: aNonyMous https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/#comment-3260 Wed, 11 Apr 2012 20:20:47 +0000 http://paxye.com/blog/?p=4466#comment-3260 What a brilliant, brilliant post about positive discipline and attachment parenting. You’ve nailed the concepts down so well. I’ve never heard the ideas and tools described so simply and concisely. Why haven’t I visited your blog before now?!

]]>
By: amber j https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/#comment-3259 Sun, 01 Apr 2012 07:26:14 +0000 http://paxye.com/blog/?p=4466#comment-3259 This is a very helpful post in the methodology of Attachment relationships with children. I find this to be very accurate as well as incredibly complex a thing to figure out how this works for each of my hildren individually. Thank you for bringing this topi to the forefront I feel as if the more attention comes to it the better.

]]>
By: Chantal https://ahippiewithaminivan.com/blog/discipline-and-how-non-punitive-parenting-works/#comment-3258 Thu, 29 Mar 2012 13:10:58 +0000 http://paxye.com/blog/?p=4466#comment-3258 Hi Mélissa,

Thanks for sharing those thoughts. I really enjoyed reading it. It is so true. I try to share it with all my parents-friends 🙂

]]>